The response
Tel Aviv Court of Peace case
#51059/05
Box 28376 Jerusalem
15 Yaacov Berav Street Jerusalem
tel: 052.669.4999
email: YitzhakRabin@gmail.com
The Defendant: Shimon Peres
Attorney Ram Caspi:
Marchov Yaacov 33 Tel Aviv 65258
tel 03.796.1000: fax 03.796.1001
1. Dear Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, It is with great sorrow that I am involved in this slander trial and the uncovering of truth pertaining to the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l. I will now go through Shimon Peres' attorney's argument one by one. Shimon Peres' attorney is claiming that I am using a lawsuit for an inappropriate matter. The sole reason of my slander lawsuit against Shimon Peres is that he, Shimon Peres, called me a "Psycho that should be institutionalized" on September 8th, 2005 in the Labor Political Party internet newspaper and refused to apologize. Shimon Peres' attorney claims from pages 2-11 that I am obsessed with the Yitzhak Rabin z"l murder conspiracy.
2. Honorable Judge Mark-Horenczyk, with my deep regret, I hate to state the obvious, but you, I and all those who are following this slander trial know with complete confidence that the killers of Yitzhak Rabin are, in fact, walking around free. I am sure that you, being a judge of this slander trial, an Israeli, and most importantly a human being have seen the various court, Shamgar commission, police and hospital documents. As well as the various video and audio evidence that is well prepared on the various web sites and links mentioned in Shimon Peres' attorney's petition to the court. In english we say "Let's not beat a dead horse" but I will mention one more time that the killer's of Yitzhak Rabin are walking around free, that is the fact which a reasonable, normal person concludes when he or she is knowledgeable of the facts surrounding the death of Yitzhak Rabin z"l.
3. Shimon Peres' attorney writes over and over that I "obsessed" with publicizing my "imaginary Rabin murder conspiracy." Firstly, it is an insult to our intelligence to use the word "conspiracy", since we know exactly what happened on November 4, 1995. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, put yourself in my shoes. I am a Jewish male who was born in the USA who has the ability to bring the true killers of Yitzhak Rabin to justice. I could not sleep for a week when I first saw the evidence in the Yitzhak Rabin murder case. Afterwards, I spoke with numerous politicians and media personal who have said that they know that the true killers of Yitzhak Rabin are free but really don't care. That really bothered me. It is very disturbing when an employee of Channel 2 tells me that he saw the original uncut 40 minute Kempler video and tells me in detail why the 40 minute Kempler video was not shown to the public. The various people who have called me brave and courageous for my actions are not correct. For me it is really simple, when you have the ability to bring justice to the true killers of a good man like Yitzhak Rabin z"l, one just acts. Obviously, not every decision that I will make in this quest will be smart or wise. But the end result will be the same, those responsible for the murder of Yitzhak Rabin will be brought to justice.
4. I, David Rutstein, am taking some very obvious risks. Firstly, the risk that I will be murdered by those who have murdered Yitzhak Rabin. Of course, I do not want to die. The act that I can do to prevent myself from getting murdered is to publicize my name personally and to publicly name names of those most likely to murder me. If, G-d forbid, I was murdered the person featured on www.ShimonPeres.net would be the obvious suspect. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, I don't want to insult your intelligence but the obvious suspect in any murder crime are those who are closest to the victim at the time of the death. In the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l ,the driver of Yitzhak Rabin's cadillac and the bodyguard who entered the backseat with Yitzhak Rabin on the way to Ichilov Hospital. The other obvious suspect would be the person who profited personally from the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l. Shimon Peres became Prime Minister of the State of Israel the moment Yitzhak Rabin z"l was declared dead.
5. The other suspect would be the person who actually oversaw the fraudulent investigation that occurred after Yitzhak Rabin's murder. Shimon Peres approved an order http://www.barrychamish.com/html/shabak_docs1.htm, as new Prime Minister, that was given on Nov 27, 1995 transferring the authority over the Yitzhak Rabin murder investigation from the Israeli police to The Shabak, Israeli secret service. The law in Israel is clear: In all cases of non-military murder, Israel Police is solely responsible for investigations. I also know, through my knowledge of history, that about half of all political assassinations throughout history are carried out by those who were assigned to protect that King, President, Emperor, Prime Minister, etc. So from a purely public relations matter, it would be really silly for Shimon Peres, the new Israeli Prime Minister, to appoint Yitzhak Rabin's security detail, the Shabak, as the murder investigators. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, I simply do not want to murdered by the same people who murdered Yitzhak Rabin z"l.
6. Honorable Judge Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, a very disturbing realization has occurred to me as I read this 24 page document filed by Shimon Peres' attorney. This 24 page document is full of references to me as a person who is an "obsessive lunatic" on a mission about an "imaginary conspiracy theory." This repeated negative reference is a very direct insinuation that I, in fact, am a "Psychopath that should be institutionalized" as was stated in the Labor Party newspaper on September 8th, 2005 by Shimon Peres' spokesman. The slanderous words by Shimon Peres' spokesman on September 8th, 2005 were explained in Shimon Peres' defense response of November 15 as "off the cuff" remark that could not be attributable to Shimon Peres because Shimon Peres did not know that I, David Rutstein, even existed. Shimon Peres did have the opportunity to apologize and still has the opportunity to apologize. Instead of apologizing, Shimon Peres, using his attorney's pen, attacks me personally as an "obsessive lunatic" on a mission about an "imaginary conspiracy theory." Shimon Peres' 24 page slander of me is deeply insulting.
7. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, before I was slandered and Shimon Peres refused to apologize, I was not willing to put on any of my web sites any direct accusations against Shimon Peres personally. Of course, we know that Yitzhak Rabin's killers are free, but I have not direct knowledge of who ordered Yitzhak Rabin's murder. The 24 page request "to throw out the slander suit" document has Shimon Peres repeatedly attacking me personally as an "obsessive lunatic" with "an imaginary conspiracy theory." This "attack mode" of Shimon Peres is a very strong indication that something very unusual is happening.
8. What did I do to so terrible to be so viciously attacked?
a. I built web sites, with catchy domain names, that put in an orderly manner the various evidence that was already available to the general public if they looked really hard on the internet.
b. I returned to the Israeli public the Ronni Kempler 10 minute video which was shown on Israeli TV once or twice in December, 1995.
c. I have spent time, effort and money doing actions that make the real killers of Yitzhak Rabin z"l more likely to be brought to trial.
d. Most importantly, I am on the verge of success, there is a very large possibility that the real killers of Yitzhak Rabin will be on trial in the near future.
8a. My Question to Shimon Peres is why would what I am doing bother you? Do I deserve to be called a "obsessive lunatic" with "an imaginary conspiracy theory?" Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, I will let you figure out the logical conclusion of this paragraph because it is too sad for me to contemplate.
9. The various actions that I have taken over the past few months have been to bring the true killers of Yitzhak Rabin z"l to justice. By the way, substantially more people get my information via email about Rabin murder than is reported by Shimon Peres's attorney. Another obvious risk that I am taking is the financial risk. If I lose this court case then I have to pay the court costs of Shimon Peres. From a purely legal perceptive, based on Israeli law, I should not lose the court case.
10. Shimon Peres did slander me on Sept 8th, 2005 and should apologize. There is a risk that the Israeli Judge is corrupt or just afraid. The Israeli Judge will be tempted to be bribed or persuaded to rule contrary to Israeli law and punish me, David Rutstein, financially. The obvious way eliminate that risk is to "guarantee" the Israeli Judge that my efforts to bring justice to the killers of Yitzhak Rabin will succeed and that punishing me financially is not a smart thing to do. By the way, my actions in the past few months are more similar to those of the French writer, Emil Zola, in the Alfred Dreyfus Case in the late 1890's France. The Israeli Kastner trial of the 1950s has similarities but my actions and those of Emil Zola are closer in nature. Obviously, I don't want the Israeli Judge to feel comfortable in not judging according to Israeli law. Therefore, making reference to trials that are historical in nature serve my financial interests.
11. Just as a side note, before I was slandered and Shimon Peres refused to appologize, on none of my web sites or actions did I ever mention that Shimon Peres ordered the murder of Yitzhak Rabin, bloody pictures, etc. So honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, if there is a desire to adhere to the letter of the law then Shimon Peres will lose the slander trial and you will force Shimon Peres to apologize to me. But I, David Rutstein, am definitely taking a financial risk suing Shimon Peres for slander and being a normal human being I really don't want to lose money. There is a possibility that I am a bit simple and pure, in that I believe very strongly for justice for Yitzhak Rabin z"l.
12. Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, I was a bit idealistic when I first came to Israel in September, 2004. I actually thought that Israel was like America, just smaller, more Jews and better people. To cut to the chase, something like the Rabin murder fraud could not continue in the United States for over 10 years or even 6 months. Because of the new technologies and freedoms that are blossoming around the world, the world is becoming more like the United States. Being knowledgeable of media and history, I am informing you that the Rabin murder fraud physically cannot last much longer in Israel!
13. Conversations with various politicians and Larissa Amir can be explained simply. These people tell me that they know that Yigal Amir did not murder Yitzhak Rabin. I am just supposed to smile, get myself killed and/or have a crooked Israeli Judge punish me financially. Of course, a normal person will do whatever they can to persuade Larissa Amir and various politicians to say loud and clear to world what they are telling me in person. That they are certain that Yitzhak Rabin's killers are free. By the way, Larissa Amir did give an internet radio interview to Israel National News in December that is stored on my site. As well Member of Knesset Nissim Zeev gave a newspaper interview to Maariv in the beginning of November in which he states that Rabin's killers are free. The newspaper only printed a small portion of what Nissim Zeev said but Nissim Zeev's interview contributed to the mini-Rabin murder boom in November, 2005. Nissim Zeev's later told me personally that Eli Yishai yelled at him for doing the interview. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, you are more than welcome to go into my personal online diary which is located at the mismachim pages at www.rotter.net. But seriously, I really don't want to be punished by a cowardly, corrupt Israeli Judge!
14. Shimon Peres' Attorney on pages 12 and 13 claims that the court documents the were filed on my behalf prove that I am using the your honorable court for purposes not related to the stated claim that I want Shimon Peres to apologize for slandering me
15. There is a very big problem in the state of Israel, any person who is knowledgeable of Yitzhak Rabin's fraudulent murder and has done nothing in the last 10 years to bring the killers of Yitzhak Rabin z"l to justice is actually guilty of a crime in itself. Knowing of a crime and doing nothing is a crime in the USA and probably in Israel as well. So how do you get a decent, honest lawyer when the entire enlightened, community has known about Yitzhak Rabin murder fraud for over 10 years and done absolutely nothing
16. Shimon Peres' Attorney writes on pages 14,15 and 16 brings many well researched examples of people who attempted to waste the honorable court's time and had their lawsuit thrown out of court. Very fine work by Shimon Peres' attorney. As I continue to page 17 of Shimon Peres' request to throw out the court case, it is mentioned of my political ambitions in the State of Israel. Firstly, my love for Yitzhak Rabin z"l is very strong, whatever it takes to bring Yitzhak Rabin's killers to justice I will do!
17. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, In the last 6 months I have spoken personally with just about with every politician in Israel (at least their office staff), political activist and media figures in english and hebrew. To cut to the chase, Left wing politicians or media will never bring up the truth on Rabin murder. I was told this thousands of times. The lone exception was the campaign of Amir Peretz for the Labor Party nomination. I was actually thanked by Amir Peretz's spokesman for helping get his boss elected. I have a slight feeling that Amir Peretz simply used Yitzhak Rabin's murder fraud to win the Labor Party nomination.
18. On the other hand, I am allowed to keep an online diary on Israeli's largest forum and news web site www.rotter.net. Rotter.net is a right wing web site and I am simply writing a bunch of words on the diary which is designed to persuade right wing activists to join my quest to bring the killers of Yitzhak Rabin to justice (keep me from getting murdered and being financially punished by a corrupt Israeli Judge). www.rotter.net. is the one Israeli media source that is truly publicizing the Rabin murder fraud and there is a strong possibility the killers of Yitzhak Rabin would have "gotten away with murder" www.barrychamish.com is in the english language and Barry Chamish is Israel's most famous Anglo journalist. In order for me to show my true love for Yitzhak Rabin it is imperative for me to "partner" with groups that are willing to donate time, money and effort to bring Yitzhak Rabin's killers to justice.
19. Honorable, Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk the online diary that Shimon Peres' attorney is quoting from in his claim for throwing out the court case is not relevant. On the Rotter diary I am writing a personal plea for these folks at rotter.net to help me in my quest to bring justice to Yitzhak Rabin z"l. On page 18 #53.1 states how I that I never mentioned the bloody pictures and such when I filed the court case, that is because the bloody pictures and obvious incitement were not there. Those pictures were only added after Shimon Peres slandered me and refused to apologize. Shimon Peres' attorney is looking to make a very simply issue of whether Shimon Peres should apologize for slander me into a very complicated matter.
20. I, David Rutstein, am responding to the 24 pages written in hebrew even though I only read only basic hebrew. If the issue is complicated then it would indicate an an irrational attempt by Shimon Peres' attorney to complicate a basic matter as to whether Shimon Peres should apologize for slandering me. An honorable judge has a basic responsibility to go by the law of the State of Israel and the law of being a good human being. So, in essence, I am putting my trust in you, as a person, to do the right thing.
21. On page 18 and 19 there is a long list of people who Barry Chamish of Modiin, Israel claims that Shimon Peres has murdered. In fact, Barry Chamish on www.barrychamish.com calls Shimon Peres a serial killer. The web site belongs Barry Chamish and the content of the web site is Barry's writings. One of the proofs that Shimon Peres is the most likely suspect in Yitzhak Rabin's z"l is that Shimon Peres has never sued Barry Chamish for slander. Barry Chamish has been running around for years with professionally looking books and is Israel's biggest international writer. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, I am only here since September, 2004 and it is really weird that Barry Chamish makes his livelihood writing books, giving lectures, radio and TV interviews about how Shimon Peres kills people. In fact if you go to google.com in english, the words Barry Chamish bring 95,200 entries. I have the numbers on the entrances to www.barrychamish.com and it is shame for the State of Israel that Barry Chamish is slandering Shimon Peres full time during the last ten years.
22. I, David Rutstein, really have no idea who many of the people are that Barry Chamish claims that Shimon Peres murdered. But the list is serious. Mr Shimon Peres should definitely have his attorney contact Barry Chamish in Modiin. Barry has a nice apartment and is earning his livelihood from calling Shimon Peres a serial killer. Really weird. On a not so humorous note, when one asks Barry Chamish what is his job? Barry Chamish can answer: "I make money from telling the world that Shimon Peres is a killer!"
23. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, it is very insulting, even slanderous to connect me to the writings of Barry Chamish. This is the second time Shimon Peres' attorney has written the list of dead people from Barry Chamish's web site. Shimon Peres' attorney knows exactly what my response will be since the attorney even heard me speak on the radio interview about this subject. The reason that I built Barry Chamish's web site is that I am embarking a a very dangerous matter, bringing Yitzhak Rabin's killer to justice. It is imperative that public knowledge about my actions reach the entire world. If , G-d forbid, I was murdered tomorrow which newspapers would put me on the front page? I can tell you right now it would be Rotter.net and Barry Chamish. Other than those two news media outlets, nothing is guaranteed. Thousands of Israelis have told me that I am endangering my life. If Barry Chamish wants me to build him a web site to make it more likely that I will continue living, that is a good deal for me.
24. Page 20 talks about being honest and I could not agree more. Page 21 brings case law on slander. Each and every Israeli knows that when you slander someone you get sued, you lose, apologize and pay some money. Based on what I am looking at on page 21 it seems that the State of Israel is a country of laws. Since I know the court case of the Yitzhak Rabin murder fraud as well as any person in Israel, I know that when the government wants to brake the law, then then law is broken. The court system really won't interfere, even if breaking the law is the murder of a Prime Minister!
25. Page 22. #61.5 Let's cut to the chase, Shimon Peres is the prime suspect in the prime suspect in the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l, and of course I would not want Shimon Peres to be the Prime Minister of Israel. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, I happen to live in Israel and love Yitzhak Rabin z"l.
26. Page 23 #67. It is obvious that Shimon Peres' spokesman made an error in slandering me on Sept 8, 2005, and that slander spread to many media outlets in a very short period of time. I even sent Shimon Peres a letter requesting an apology. It is true that Shimon Peres refused to apologize for the slander and Shimon Peres defense response states that I was not damaged by the slander. Does Shimon Peres have special knowledge of my damages or lack of damages? Shimon Peres never called me to ask me about my welfare, or simply ask "how I am doing"? or what he can do to "make up" for the slip of the tongue of his spokesman.
27. The only thing that Shimon Peres did was make a phone call to cancel my pay per click on google.co.il. My web sites provide the first time an Israeli could see the 10 minute Ronni Kempler video since 1995. It became clear to me that Shimon Peres was behind, the media coverup of the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z'l . Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, please look at my personnel web site www.davidrutstein.com at Sept 16, 2005 you can see the Eyton Haeer article. There was nothing in that Eyton Haeer article of my slandering Shimon Peres personally, Eyton Haeer is just saying the I am advertising the Rabin conspiracy. The only thing that was mentioned is the Eytan Cabel of the Labor Party is filing a police complaint Barry Chamish. It should be known that no police complaint or lawsuit was ever filed against Barry Chamish.
28. The headlines on the my web sites before Sept 8 were simply the "killers are free" which is what many famous people have told me personally since I arrived in Israel and some influential Israeli's have said publicly since this November. In addition, on the Yigal Amir web site the headline was "I did not murder him", which is what Yigal Amir, through his wife Larissa, is saying publicly since January, 2006. Honorable, Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, your court room is not and will not be the place to uncover the truth about a murder that happened 10 years ago, but we do want Shimon Peres to be honest in a simple slander lawsuit filed by a fellow citizen.
29. In conclusion, Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, this court case is not about me, David Rutstein, or Shimon Peres. The truth is coming to the whole world in the very near future regarding the true circumstances of the death of Yitzhak Rabin z"l. The non-following of the law by many of those who sit in judgment of others as State of Israeli Judges is a real issue. I know absolutely nothing about the Israeli legal system except one murder trial. The trial of Yigal Amir for the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l. I am positive you know quite a bit about what happened on the night on Nov 4, 1995 that you did not know previously because of my actions which were initially based on my great love for Yitzhak Rabin z"l. So forgive me for being cavalier in thinking that many powerful Israelis are criminals. But what is a normal person supposed to think after knowing what I know surrounding the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l? Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, If we ever meet in person you will be certain that I had and continue to have only good intentions in taking up the cause to bring justice to the soul of Yitzhak Rabin z"l.
30. By the way, the 100 questions that were given to me by Shimon Peres' attorney in January, in my opinion, should be answered only if the trial continues. As well, many of the questions are an attempt to humiliate me further. So much time and effort by Shimon Peres' attorney when all Shimon Peres has to do is apologize. Is this a rational action of an innocent person?
31. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, however, this slander trial is not about the murder of Yitzhak Rabin z"l. The court's time is valuable and serving a 24 page (to date a total of 43 written pages have been filed by Shimon Peres' attorney) request to throw out the slander suit is a terrible insult to the court. Shimon Peres just had to say "I am sorry" but decided to insult me even further by writing 24 pages of slander. We all know the very definite civil penalties in the State of Israel against slander and this is a very simple case. Honorable Judge Dalia Mark-Horenczyk, good luck in your decision and may G-d bless you.
All the Best,
David Rutstein
No comments:
Post a Comment